Scottish Challenge CupFull timeFeatured

Predictions graded

Formartine United2Edinburgh City0

HT 0–0Sat 26 Sept 2026, 14:00 Predictions graded

Predictions6–650%

Edges2–529%

Quick Take

Pre-match view

Context last updated 25 Sep 2026, 17:21 · Europe/Bucharest

Highland League hosts against League Two visitors: Formartine have scored in every home game, Edinburgh City have kept three clean sheets in seven away.

Edinburgh City are the single most likely winner, but 1.88 asks more than their away form supports. Two prices hold up — Formartine to win or draw at 1.85 and the draw at 4.0.

Context

Formartine have already won a home tie against SPFL opposition in this competition this season, so the Highland League hosts bring a recent, venue-specific result rather than league form alone. Edinburgh City arrive with a high-scoring recent run of their own, which makes the league-stage tie a real cross-division test instead of a formality. The same venue also suits a side that has been scoring freely at home in its own league. The limitation is that Montrose are a different opponent with different priorities, so one cup night at North Lodge Park cannot tell us how Formartine will set up against a League Two side.
- Formartine United beat Montrose 3-2 at North Lodge Park on 22 September 2026 in the KDM Evolution Trophy.
- The same night's results included Edinburgh City 1-0 Dundee United B, Elgin City 3-0 Dundee B, Forfar Athletic 0-2 Peterhead and Fraserburgh 0-5 Cove Rangers.
- A round-up of that night's competition led on victories for Elgin City, Formartine, Cove Rangers, Peterhead and Ross County.
ConfirmedSources checked 25 Sep 2026, 17:18 · Europe/Bucharest
This is the league stage of the Scottish Challenge Cup, so a League Two club travels north to a Highland League ground rather than the reverse, and the visitors count this as their fifth tie of the campaign. The away club's pre-match detail has the ground opening an hour before the 15:00 start, with tickets bought at the turnstiles, which makes the day quite unlike a normal League Two Saturday. For Edinburgh City the trip and the venue are the practical differences from a league fixture. Nothing in the evidence indicates how strong a side either club will field.
- Edinburgh City are away to Formartine United at North Lodge Park in the KDM Evolution Trophy, counted by the away club as game five of the competition.
- Ground opens at 14:00 on Saturday 26 September, with tickets sold on the day by cash or card.
- The Challenge Cup league-stage tie kicks off at 15:00 at North Lodge Park.
ConfirmedSources checked 25 Sep 2026, 17:18 · Europe/BucharestMatch pagewww.bbc.co.uk · 25 Sep 2026
Edinburgh City's away record is built on fast starts and a defence that has not been breached before the interval on their travels.
Formartine average a goal each way in home first halves, so an early away goal is a live possibility, but the hosts score 1.38 goals after the break at home while Edinburgh City concede 1.14 a game in the second half away — the later stages are where this tie may swing.
- Seven Edinburgh City away matches tracked between 18 July and 19 September 2026: 1.43 first-half goals scored per match, 0 first-half goals conceded, 0.43 second-half goals scored and 1.14 second-half goals conceded.
- In those seven away matches they scored six goals and conceded four, keeping three clean sheets and seeing both teams score in three of them.
Edinburgh City carry three Hearts players under a cooperation agreement, and the only Challenge Cup football those players have played this season has been for Hearts B, who are in the same competition. That is worth knowing when reading the Edinburgh City line-up for a cup tie, because the side at North Lodge Park need not resemble the one that has been collecting League Two points. The sourcing is a single loan-watch summary rather than a club statement, so the eligibility picture for this specific tie is unresolved. Read it as a guide to squad shape rather than a settled selection fact.
- Three Hearts players are at Edinburgh City under a cooperation agreement.
- Their minutes in this competition this season have come for Hearts B rather than for Edinburgh City.
- One of the three started Edinburgh City's last two League Two matches before mid-September.
ReportedSources checked 25 Sep 2026, 17:18 · Europe/Bucharest

BetBugs edges

Compare BetBugs' chances with the market's.

Positive edges · 4

BetBugs probabilities

How likely BetBugs thought each outcome was.

Result3 of 5 landed

Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Near coin-flip · Not priced
The read
Edinburgh City's higher-division quality and away defensive record give them a real chance, though Formartine's home scoring makes it close.
- Edinburgh City are 4W-1D-2L away, scoring 1.86 goals per away match.
- Edinburgh City have 5 clean sheets in 15 overall and 3 in 7 away matches.
- They beat Dundee United B 1-0 in their most recent Challenge Cup tie on 22 September.
- Formartine have conceded in 7 of 8 home matches.
BetBugs · Match WinnerlostEdinburgh CityEstimated chance37%
Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Near coin-flip · Market price 2.30
The read
Edinburgh City's away first-half scoring record and Formartine's home concession rate point to an away half-time lead.
- Edinburgh City average 1.43 first-half goals away and have conceded none in 7 away matches.
- Formartine concede 1.00 first-half goals at home.
- Edinburgh City scored 5 first-half goals against Stirling Albion on 12 September.
BetBugs · First Half WinnerlostEdinburgh CityEstimated chance44%
Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Near coin-flip · Not priced
The read
Formartine's strong second-half home record and Edinburgh City's tendency to concede after the break make a home second-half win the most likely outcome.
- Formartine average 1.38 second-half goals at home and concede 0.63.
- Edinburgh City average 0.43 second-half goals away and concede 1.14.
- Edinburgh City have conceded more second-half goals than first-half goals overall.
BetBugs · Second Half WinnerwonFormartine UnitedEstimated chance48%
Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Strong lean · Not priced
The read
Formartine's strong home scoring and recent home cup win over higher-division Montrose give them a solid chance, but Edinburgh City's division edge keeps this close. Edinburgh City's higher-division quality and away defensive record give them a real chance, though Formartine's home scoring makes it close.
- Formartine are 4W-2D-2L at home with 2.38 goals scored per home match.
- Edinburgh City have lost 2 of 7 away matches and concede 1.14 goals per away game.
- Edinburgh City are 4W-1D-2L away, scoring 1.86 goals per away match.
- Edinburgh City have 5 clean sheets in 15 overall and 3 in 7 away matches.
BetBugs · Double ChancewonFormartine United or Edinburgh CityEstimated chance71%
Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Strong lean · Market price 1.22
The read
Both teams have mixed first-half records, and a level half-time score is plausible. Edinburgh City's away first-half scoring record and Formartine's home concession rate point to an away half-time lead.
- Formartine home first halves average 1.00 goal for and 1.00 against.
- Edinburgh City away first halves average 1.43 goals for and 0.00 against.
- Edinburgh City average 1.43 first-half goals away and have conceded none in 7 away matches.
- Formartine concede 1.00 first-half goals at home.
BetBugs · Double Chance First HalfwonDraw or Edinburgh CityEstimated chance82%

Goals3 of 7 landed

Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Lean · Market price 1.50
The read
Both teams score and concede at rates that make three or more goals likely.
- Formartine home matches average 4.00 total goals (2.38 for, 1.63 against).
- Edinburgh City away matches average 3.00 total goals (1.86 for, 1.14 against).
- Both teams have recent high-scoring games, including Edinburgh City's 7-3 win over Stirling Albion.
BetBugs · Goals Over/UnderlostOver 2.5Estimated chance62%
Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Lean · Market price 1.50
The read
Formartine's home scoring and Edinburgh City's away scoring make both teams finding the net likely.
- Formartine have scored in all 8 home matches and both teams scored in 7 of those 8.
- Edinburgh City scored in 6 of 7 away matches.
- Formartine's home matches average 2.38 goals for and 1.63 against.
BetBugs · Both Teams to ScorelostYesEstimated chance60%
Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Lean · Not priced
The read
Formartine's home scoring rate makes two or more goals likely.
- Formartine average 2.38 goals per home match.
- They scored in all 8 home matches.
- Edinburgh City concede 1.14 goals per away match.
BetBugs · Home Goals TotalwonFormartine United over 1.5Estimated chance60%
Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Slight lean · Not priced
The read
Edinburgh City's away scoring and Formartine's home concession rate make two or more away goals more likely than not.
- Edinburgh City average 1.86 goals per away match.
- They scored in 6 of 7 away matches.
- Formartine concede 1.63 goals per home match.
BetBugs · Away Goals TotallostEdinburgh City over 1.5Estimated chance55%
Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Strong lean · Market price 1.22
The read
Both teams' first-half scoring and conceding rates make at least one first-half goal very likely.
- Formartine home first halves average 2.00 total goals (1.00 for, 1.00 against).
- Edinburgh City away first halves average 1.43 total goals (1.43 for, 0.00 against).
- Edinburgh City scored 5 first-half goals in a recent match.
BetBugs · 1st Half GoalslostOver 0.5 goals in 1st halfEstimated chance80%
Signal quality Low · Uncertainty band Strong lean · Not priced
The read
Edinburgh City's away first-half defensive record makes it less likely both teams score before half-time.
- Edinburgh City have conceded no first-half goals in 7 away matches.
- Formartine have kept one clean sheet in 8 home matches, but their first-half defence concedes 1.00 at home.
- Edinburgh City's first-half scoring is high, so one team often leads without the other scoring.
BetBugs · Both Teams Score First HalfwonNoEstimated chance70%
Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Lean · Not priced
The read
Both teams' second-half averages suggest a reasonable chance of two or more goals after the break.
- Formartine home second halves average 2.00 total goals (1.38 for, 0.63 against).
- Edinburgh City away second halves average 1.57 total goals (0.43 for, 1.14 against).
- Edinburgh City have conceded 1.14 second-half goals per away match.
BetBugs · Goals Over Under Second HalfwonOver 1.5Estimated chance58%

Recent Form

Formartine United

W3-0LossiemouthSep 19FOO

D1-1FraserburghSep 16FOO

D1-1ClachnacuddinSep 12FOO

L2-3Dundee United IISep 8CHA

D1-1Nairn CountySep 5FOO

W2-1Forres MechanicsAug 29FOO

W4-1KeithAug 22FOO

W4-2RothesAug 19FOO

W2-1InvergordonAug 15FOO

W4-1Dundee IIAug 11CHA

D2-2HuntlyAug 8FOO

L0-1Turriff UnitedAug 5FOO

L1-4Brora RangersAug 1FOO

W2-1Strathspey ThistleJul 25FOO

W2-1Forres MechanicsApr 11FOO

Edinburgh City

W3-1Kelty HeartsSep 19LEA

W7-3Stirling AlbionSep 12LEA

D1-1Queen of the SouthSep 8CHA

L2-3ClydeSep 5LEA

D1-1Forfar AthleticAug 28LEA

W1-0Hamilton AcademicalAug 25CHA

W1-0Annan AthleticAug 22LEA

W3-0DumbartonAug 15LEA

W3-1CowdenbeathAug 11CHA

D2-2SpartansAug 8LEA

L0-5Elgin CityAug 1LEA

W2-0StranraerJul 21LEA

L0-2Ayr UtdJul 18LEA

W2-0Alloa AthleticJul 14LEA

L0-5FalkirkJul 11LEA

Squad & Injuries

Formartine United

30 available

Attackers6

Midfielders10

Defenders9

Goalkeeper5

Edinburgh City

30 available

Attackers5

Midfielders12

Defenders8

Goalkeeper5

Quick Take

Context

BetBugs edges

Formartine United or Draw

Draw

Draw or Edinburgh City

Edinburgh City

Over 0.5 goals in 1st half

Over 2.5

Yes

Result3 of 5 landed

Goals3 of 7 landed

Recent Form

Formartine United

Edinburgh City

Squad & Injuries

Formartine United

Edinburgh City