Scottish Challenge CupFull timeFeatured

Predictions graded

Formartine United3Montrose2

HT 1–0Tue 22 Sept 2026, 18:45 Predictions graded

Predictions9–375%

Edges4–357%

Quick Take

Pre-match view

Context last updated 22 Sep 2026, 16:25 · Europe/Bucharest

Highland League hosts against a League One side on a six-match winning run in all competitions: Montrose are the likelier winners, but Formartine score in every home match in the sample, so a comfortable away afternoon is not guaranteed.

A first-half goal at 1.20 and under 2.5 goals at 2.40 both carry a small edge; Montrose at 1.78, over 2.5 at 1.50 and both teams to score at 1.57 are priced shorter than they warrant.

Context

Montrose's sample contains no drawn match at all, home or away, so every game in it was settled.
A record without a single draw in 15 matches points to this tie being resolved one way or the other, which stands against Formartine's tendency to draw at home; the four defeats show the decisive result can also fall against Montrose.
- Montrose overall, 14 July 2026 to 19 September 2026: 15 competitive matches, 11 wins, 0 draws, 4 defeats.
- Montrose scored 1.73 and conceded 1.13 per match across that 15-match sample.
- Montrose kept seven clean sheets in those 15 matches.
Formartine's eight-match home split reads 4W-2D-2L, with 2.38 goals scored and 1.63 conceded per match.
That scoring run is the strongest argument against a straightforward Montrose win, and it carries a caution for the home side too: both teams scored in seven of those eight matches, so few of those games were controlled from start to finish.
- Formartine home split, 11 April 2026 to 19 September 2026: eight matches, 4W-2D-2L.
- Formartine scored in all eight home matches, at 2.38 goals per match, and conceded 1.63 per match.
- Both teams scored in seven of those eight home matches.
Formartine United and Montrose have no competitive meeting inside the available record.
A single friendly more than four years old is far too small and too dated a sample to say anything about how this cup tie will be played, though it is the only direct reference either side has for the fixture.
- Head-to-head sample: one match, a friendly on 25 June 2022, Montrose 4-3 Formartine United.
- The record contains no competitive meeting between the two clubs.
It is the only Challenge Cup fixture among Formartine's six most recent matches.
One match is thin evidence, but it shows Formartine can concede three at home in this competition and still score twice after the break, which fits the home-scoring pattern running through the rest of their record.
- Formartine United 2-3 Dundee United II, Challenge Cup, 8 September 2026, played at Formartine.
- Formartine trailed 0-2 at half-time and scored both of their goals in the second half.

BetBugs edges

Compare BetBugs' chances with the market's.

Positive edges · 2

Other edges · 5

The published chance does not exceed the market's implied chance.

Double ChancewonUncertainty band: Strong lean

Formartine United or Montrose

1.25fair 1.33

BetBugs 75% · Market 80%

−5.0ppshort

Formartine's home scoring and Montrose's away form leave the home win possible but not clearly favoured. Montrose's higher-league form and six straight wins make them the stronger side, though away in the cup keeps it from being clear.

Both Teams Score First HalfwonUncertainty band: Strong lean

No

1.25fair 1.39

BetBugs 72% · Market 80%

−8.0ppshort

Montrose's recent first-half clean sheets make both teams scoring before the break unlikely.

Both Teams to ScorewonUncertainty band: Lean

Yes

1.57fair 1.61

BetBugs 62% · Market 63.7%

−1.7ppshort

Both sides score regularly in these splits, so both finding the net is more likely than not.

BetBugs probabilities

How likely BetBugs thought each outcome was.

Result2 of 5 landed

Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Near coin-flip · Market price 1.78
The read
Montrose's higher-league form and six straight wins make them the stronger side, though away in the cup keeps it from being clear.
- Montrose overall: 11W-0D-4L, 1.73 goals scored and 1.13 conceded per match.
- Montrose away: 4W-0D-2L, 1.67 goals scored and 1.00 conceded per match.
- Montrose have won their last six matches in all competitions.
- Formartine lost 2-3 at home to Dundee United II in the Challenge Cup.
BetBugs · Match WinnerlostMontroseEstimated chance48%
Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Near coin-flip · Market price 2.15
The read
Montrose's strong first-half scoring and Formartine's home first-half concessions make an away half-time lead the most likely single outcome.
- Montrose away first-half goals: 1.33 per match.
- Montrose away first-half conceded: 0.50 per match.
- Montrose led at half-time in all six recent matches.
- Formartine home first-half conceded: 1.00 per match.
BetBugs · First Half WinnerlostMontroseEstimated chance46%
Signal quality Low · Uncertainty band Near coin-flip · Not priced
The read
Both teams have often drawn recent second halves, making a level second half a reasonable outcome.
- Formartine's last six second halves: 2 wins, 3 draws, 1 loss.
- Montrose's last six second halves: 2 wins, 3 draws, 1 loss.
- Formartine home second-half goal difference: +0.75 per match.
- Montrose away second-half goal difference: -0.17 per match.
BetBugs · Second Half WinnerwonDrawEstimated chance35%
Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Strong lean · Market price 1.25
The read
Formartine's home scoring and Montrose's away form leave the home win possible but not clearly favoured. Montrose's higher-league form and six straight wins make them the stronger side, though away in the cup keeps it from being clear.
- Formartine home record: 4W-2D-2L, 2.38 goals scored per home match.
- Montrose away record: 4W-0D-2L, 1.00 goals conceded per away match.
- Montrose overall: 11W-0D-4L, 1.73 goals scored and 1.13 conceded per match.
- Montrose away: 4W-0D-2L, 1.67 goals scored and 1.00 conceded per match.
BetBugs · Double ChancewonFormartine United or MontroseEstimated chance75%
Signal quality Low · Uncertainty band Strong lean · Not priced
The read
A level first half is possible, but Montrose's recent habit of early leads lowers the draw chance. Montrose's strong first-half scoring and Formartine's home first-half concessions make an away half-time lead the most likely single outcome.
- Formartine home first-half goals for and against both average 1.00.
- Montrose away first-half conceded: 0.50 per match.
- Montrose away first-half goals: 1.33 per match.
BetBugs · Double Chance First HalflostDraw or MontroseEstimated chance77%

Goals7 of 7 landed

Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Slight lean · Not priced
The read
Formartine's home games and Montrose's decent scoring rate point to enough goals for the over.
- Formartine home matches average 4.00 total goals (2.38 for, 1.63 against).
- Montrose away matches average 2.67 total goals (1.67 for, 1.00 against).
- Formartine overall matches average 3.47 total goals.
- Montrose overall matches average 2.87 total goals.
BetBugs · Goals Over/UnderwonOver 2.5Estimated chance56%
Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Lean · Market price 1.57
The read
Both sides score regularly in these splits, so both finding the net is more likely than not.
- Formartine scored in 14 of 15 overall and in all 8 home matches.
- Montrose scored in 12 of 15 overall and in 5 of 6 away matches.
- Formartine conceded in 7 of 8 home matches.
- Both teams scored in 13 of Formartine's 15 matches.
BetBugs · Both Teams to ScorewonYesEstimated chance62%
Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Lean · Not priced
The read
Formartine's home scoring rate makes two or more home goals a reasonable possibility.
- Formartine home goals: 2.38 per match.
- Formartine scored in all 8 home matches in the sample.
- Formartine overall goals: 2.07 per match.
- Montrose away conceded 1.00 per match.
BetBugs · Home Goals TotalwonFormartine United over 1.5Estimated chance60%
Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Strong lean · Not priced
The read
Formartine's home scoring record makes it likely they score at least once.
- Formartine scored in all 8 home matches in the sample.
- Formartine scored in 14 of 15 overall.
- Montrose away clean sheets: 3 in 6 matches.
- Montrose overall clean sheets: 7 in 15 matches.
BetBugs · Team to ScorewonFormartine United to scoreEstimated chance87%
Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Strong lean · Market price 1.20
The read
Both teams score early often, so a first-half goal is strongly likely.
- Formartine home first-half goals: 1.00 per match.
- Montrose away first-half goals: 1.33 per match.
- Montrose scored in the first half of all six recent matches.
- Formartine's last six first halves all had at least one goal.
BetBugs · 1st Half GoalswonOver 0.5 goals in 1st halfEstimated chance88%
Signal quality Medium · Uncertainty band Strong lean · Market price 1.25
The read
Montrose's recent first-half clean sheets make both teams scoring before the break unlikely.
- Montrose conceded zero first-half goals across their last six matches.
- Formartine scored in the first half of four of their last six matches.
- Montrose away first-half conceded: 0.50 per match.
- Formartine home first-half conceded: 1.00 per match.
BetBugs · Both Teams Score First HalfwonNoEstimated chance72%
Signal quality Low · Uncertainty band Slight lean · Not priced
The read
The combined second-half scoring rates put the over just ahead, but the edge is small.
- Formartine home second-half goals: 1.38 per match.
- Montrose away second-half goals: 0.33 per match.
- Formartine home second-half conceded: 0.63 per match.
- Montrose away second-half conceded: 0.50 per match.
BetBugs · Goals Over Under Second HalfwonOver 1.5Estimated chance53%

Head-to-Head

0W · 0D · 1W

L4-3MontrosevFormartine UnitedJun 25, 2022FRI

7 goals/game avg

Recent Form

Formartine United

W3-0LossiemouthSep 19FOO

D1-1FraserburghSep 16FOO

D1-1ClachnacuddinSep 12FOO

L2-3Dundee United IISep 8CHA

D1-1Nairn CountySep 5FOO

W2-1Forres MechanicsAug 29FOO

W4-1KeithAug 22FOO

W4-2RothesAug 19FOO

W2-1InvergordonAug 15FOO

W4-1Dundee IIAug 11CHA

D2-2HuntlyAug 8FOO

L0-1Turriff UnitedAug 5FOO

L1-4Brora RangersAug 1FOO

W2-1Strathspey ThistleJul 25FOO

W2-1Forres MechanicsApr 11FOO

Montrose

W2-1East FifeSep 19LEA

W2-1Cove RangersSep 12LEA

W3-2Dundee IISep 8CHA

W3-0PeterheadSep 5LEA

W2-1Queen of the SouthAug 29LEA

W3-0ClydeAug 25CHA

W3-0East KilbrideAug 22LEA

L0-3Alloa AthleticAug 15LEA

W2-0FraserburghAug 11CHA

L1-2Ross CountyAug 8LEA

L0-5Hamilton AcademicalAug 1LEA

L0-2SpartansJul 25LEA

W2-0ArbroathJul 21LEA

W2-0Stirling AlbionJul 18LEA

W1-0Dundee UtdJul 14LEA

Squad & Injuries

Formartine United

30 available

Attackers6

Midfielders10

Defenders9

Goalkeeper5

Montrose

25 available

Attackers3

Midfielders11

Defenders9

Goalkeeper2

Quick Take

Context

BetBugs edges

Over 0.5 goals in 1st half

Under 2.5

Formartine United or Montrose

No

Yes

Montrose

Montrose

Result2 of 5 landed

Goals7 of 7 landed

Head-to-Head

Recent Form

Formartine United

Montrose

Squad & Injuries

Formartine United

Montrose